Breast cancer is the most commonly diagnosed cancer and the leading cause of cancer death in women worldwide [1]. Surgical treatment has changed significantly in recent years, with breast-conserving surgery being the preferred treatment for early-stage invasive breast cancer [2]. Nowadays, percutaneous techniques are also beginning to be considered as an alternative due to their benefits. Among the different thermal ablation techniques, cryoablation has the advantage of not requiring general anesthesia. Also there are no indication limits regarding skin or the pectoral fascia and big lesions can be treated.
Our preferred treatment for the management of elderly patients
This procedure can be a good treatment option in patients unsuitable for surgery because of age or comorbilities. In our hospital, we have treated over 160 patients with cryoablation as an alternative to surgery, achieving a 93% of local control. In this cases, it is very important to combine the ablation of the tumour with endocrine therapy, to ensure a good long-term response [3].
A near future: non-surgical management of early breast cancer
Cryoablation can also be considered in early breast cancer. Thanks to screening programs and better equipment, now we can detect very small tumors, candidates for breast-conserving surgery. In 2004, Sabel et al published a study in which 27 invasive ductal carcinoma (IDC) less than 10 mm were treated with cryoablation. Then surgery was perfomed, with 100% success rate, meaning no invasive carcinoma left in the surgical specimen [4]. In 2015 and 2016 there was a similar study by Poplack et al [5] and by Acosog [6], with very promising results. In 2014 started the Ice3, a multicentric trial similar to the studies mentioned above, avoiding surgery after cryoablation. Final results are expected by december 2024, with no recurrence rate so far between 95 and 99% [7].
Considering this data, in April 2021 we started a trial in our hospital in this group of patients too [8]. We treat low risk breast carcinoma with cryoablation and, after surgery, our aim is to proof that there’s no infiltrating tumour left in the surgical specimen. Our results until April 2023 are the following. We have treated 52 cases of IDC less than 20 mm: 32 pure infiltrating carcinoma and 20 mixed, meaning intraductal component associated. After cryoablation, in the surgical specimen, there were no invasive component left in 100% of the cases of pure carcinoma, and in 80% of the mixed carcinomas. Overall, we had a success rate of a 92%, and all the lesions had tumor-free margins [9].
Cryoablation is also a very safe and well tolerated procedure. None of our patients had any complications.